“I Can See Russia From My House!”
No, this isn’t a blog about politics. But I do intend to use politics to make a point about something. Marketers work very hard to come up with tag lines that can be used to “brand” products. But sometimes this branding happens spontaneously, and I think we could learn something by looking at how and why that happens.
Think about the way in which presidents, vice presidents, and candidates are so often branded, for good or ill, by one telling phrase. For Nixon, it was (cue lowered eyebrows, shaking jowls, and guttural voice) , “I’m not a crook.” For Reagan, “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!” (Reagan was lucky; if Afghanistan hadn’t crashed the Soviet Union, Reagan’s defining line would probably have been the endless dazed “I don’t remember” from the Iran-Contra hearings.) Clinton? Take your pick: “I did not have sex with that woman.” Or, “That depends on what the meaning of is is.” Bush II? “You’re doin’ a heck of a job, Brownie!” (closely followed by Mission Accomplished and “Bring it on.”) Think about Dan Quayle and what comes to mind? Potatoe.” Hart? The Monkey Business.
These politicians did not choose these phrases as their defining tags; the media and the public chose for them. Why? Because for some reason, these phrases resonated with people. We see this sort of thing happen with movies, too. Think about Make my day. I see dead people. Show me the money. You had me with hello.
Why do these phrases become so iconic? I don’t know. It doesn’t seem to happen as often with books. True, most people would recognize the first line from Pride and Prejudice. Gone with the Wind gave us three lines: As God is my witness I’ll never be hungry again, Tomorrow is another day, and Frankly, dear, I don’t give a damn. But were those phrases so well known before the movie? I don’t doubt there are other examples from books, but it says something that I can’t think of them.
Still, I suspect we could learn something important by studying these phrases and thinking about the way they click. So, thoughts, anyone?
p.s. I know Sarah Palin actually said you can see Russia from Alaska. But because Tina Fey’s line so wonderfully captured the essence of the absurdity of the original, that’s the phrase that will forever characterize Palin (that and the turkey massacre).
Think about the way in which presidents, vice presidents, and candidates are so often branded, for good or ill, by one telling phrase. For Nixon, it was (cue lowered eyebrows, shaking jowls, and guttural voice) , “I’m not a crook.” For Reagan, “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!” (Reagan was lucky; if Afghanistan hadn’t crashed the Soviet Union, Reagan’s defining line would probably have been the endless dazed “I don’t remember” from the Iran-Contra hearings.) Clinton? Take your pick: “I did not have sex with that woman.” Or, “That depends on what the meaning of is is.” Bush II? “You’re doin’ a heck of a job, Brownie!” (closely followed by Mission Accomplished and “Bring it on.”) Think about Dan Quayle and what comes to mind? Potatoe.” Hart? The Monkey Business.
These politicians did not choose these phrases as their defining tags; the media and the public chose for them. Why? Because for some reason, these phrases resonated with people. We see this sort of thing happen with movies, too. Think about Make my day. I see dead people. Show me the money. You had me with hello.
Why do these phrases become so iconic? I don’t know. It doesn’t seem to happen as often with books. True, most people would recognize the first line from Pride and Prejudice. Gone with the Wind gave us three lines: As God is my witness I’ll never be hungry again, Tomorrow is another day, and Frankly, dear, I don’t give a damn. But were those phrases so well known before the movie? I don’t doubt there are other examples from books, but it says something that I can’t think of them.
Still, I suspect we could learn something important by studying these phrases and thinking about the way they click. So, thoughts, anyone?
p.s. I know Sarah Palin actually said you can see Russia from Alaska. But because Tina Fey’s line so wonderfully captured the essence of the absurdity of the original, that’s the phrase that will forever characterize Palin (that and the turkey massacre).
posted by cs harris at 4:12 PM
6 Comments:
We should talk about this in the writing group sometime. A very interesting topic.
A lot of people get paid a lot of money to try to MAKE phrases, images, etc. as 'sticky' as those lines.
I think the reason examples from books are harder to come by is that what 'sticks' in a story is a moment. In a movie, a small child crying 'Come back, Shane! Come back!' is a moment. In a book, it's a line of dialogue.
When I think of books I've loved, the ones that really stuck with me, what I generally remember is a defining moment, not a particular phrase.
Another interesting thing about "stickiness" is that it seems to happen much more easily with music. "Gillgan's Island" went off the air decades ago and yet the theme song still plays in my head sometimes.
Shauna, did you know you can sing "Amazing Grace" to the tune of "Gilligan's Island", and vice versa?
Charles, I really would like to talk about this in the group. We missed you last night; hope you feel better soon!
Steve, I think you're right; that difference between the essense of a moment in movies vs. books.
Shauna, I think you've hit on another part of it--the way we remember things we hear vs. the things we read. And yeah, I can still sing that entire silly Giligan song. Although Steve, I don't think I'd want to try it with the words of Amazing Grace!
just put your lips together and blow...
play it, sam...
bogey
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home